Public Safety and the role of the Victim

2007 Jun 16 Posted by Joseph Pascarella

The initial entry on this blog, “The Daunting Task of Public Safety” posted on May 13, 2007; we discussed the tragic event at Virginia Tech University and the evolutionary changes in Public Safety. One of the changes in the Public Safety and how Public Safety functions are dependent on external societal expectations in the administration of justice.

The Associate Press reported yesterday that the panel led by W. Gerald Massengil investigating the incident would be allowed to review limited health information and that family members of the victims of the massacre are attempting to obtain position (s) on the panel.

There are two issues, one involving release of health information and the other is the complex role of the victim (in this case, family members of the victims) in the justice process. The criminal justice system has evolved into complex, formal, and centralized government function that attempts to administer justice based on facts of the case, and not emotion. Aside from a Victim Impact Statement (VIS) that a judge can review prior to sentencing, the individual role of the victim beyond witness testimony is very limited. Emotional, heart wrenching incidents such as the Virginia Tech massacre sometimes compel us to reflect on what, if any, should be the role in administering justice.

This is exacerbated considering the contemporary threats to the United States and the role of the victim and victim’s family after a large scale disaster or terror attack. What should be the role of the victim in the process and what is the responsibility of the government in the long term?

Joseph Pascarella

Leave a Reply

Let us know what you think. All comments will be reviewed prior to going live. Comments that are profane or obscene, or unrelated to the topic of the post will not be published.

About

Public Safety Signals provides a venue for those working or interested in the public safety field to join in a conversation about the latest news, trends and important issues related to public safety.

Authors

Picture of Dr. Steven Barthelmeus, aa contributor to Capella's public safety blog.
Dr. Steven Barthelmeus
Program Chair,
Public Safety – Criminal Justice/Forensics program, Capella University
Picture of Harry Carter, a contributor to Capella's public safety blog.
Dr. Harry Carter
Core Faculty Member,
Capella University
Picture of Shelly Gill, a contributor to Capella's public safety blog.
Dr. Shelly Gill
Adjunct Instructor, Capella University
Picture of Dr. Joseph Pascarella, author of Capella's public safety news blog.
Dr. Joseph Pascarella
Core Faculty Member, Capella University
Picture of Dr. Jeffrey Rush, author of Capella's public safety news blog.
Dr. Jeffrey Rush
Asst. Professor of Criminal Justice/Homeland Security, Dept. of Public Management and Criminal Justice, Austin Peay State University
Picture of Dr. Michael Kemp, author of Capella's public safety news blog.
Dr. Michael Kemp
Chair, Emergency Management, Capella University
Melissa Beasley
Captain, Florence Alabama Police Department
Darryl Jones
Capella University Learner and Chief, Pittsburgh Bureau of Fire
Dr. Laura Pettler
Investigator for Prosecutorial District Twenty A of North Carolina
Mark Rubin
Capella University Learner
Mark S. Warnick
Capella University Learner, Retired Asst. Fire Chief

Archives

Alpha Phi Sigma

Links

Podcast

Public Safety Faculty Forum

Public Safety Jobs

Public Safety Learner Forum

Public Safety Network

Public Safety Web sites

Feed